Bright Data vs Oxylabs: Which One is Better in 2026?

Choosing between Bright Data and Oxylabs is like choosing between Ferrari and Lamborghini. Both are elite, but they serve slightly different needs. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll break down everything you need to know to make the right choice for your use case.

Summary Table: Head-to-Head Comparison

Feature	Bright Data	Oxylabs
Pool Size	72M+	175M+
Starting Price	$5.04/GB	$8/GB
Success Rate	99.9%	99.2%
Avg Response Time	0.45s	0.55s
Targeting	City, ZIP, ASN, Carrier	City, ASN, State
Dashboard	Enterprise Grade	Professional

Key Differences

When to Choose Bright Data

Bright Data is more than a proxy provider—it’s a comprehensive data collection platform. If you need advanced tools like the Dataset Marketplace or Web Scraper IDE, this is your go-to solution.

Bright Data excels in:

• Advanced Scraping Tools — Built-in IDE, pre-built scrapers, and dataset marketplace
• Superior Success Rate — 99.9% success rate vs Oxylabs’ 99.2%
• Faster Response Times — 0.45s average vs 0.55s for Oxylabs
• Granular Targeting — City, ZIP, ASN, and Carrier-level targeting
• Enterprise Dashboard — Advanced analytics and management features

Best for: Developers who need a “one-stop-shop” for data, enterprise scraping operations, and teams requiring advanced compliance features.

When to Choose Oxylabs

Oxylabs focuses on raw power and infrastructure reliability. With the largest residential IP pool in the industry (175M+), they prioritize coverage and stability.

Oxylabs excels in:

• Massive IP Pool — 175M+ IPs vs Bright Data’s 72M+
• Premium Support — 24/7 dedicated account managers for enterprise clients
• Global Coverage — Better representation in emerging markets
• Simplicity — Straightforward setup and integration

Best for: Large enterprise companies that need maximum coverage, stability for critical infrastructure, and premium 24/7 technical support with deep-tech understanding.

Pricing Battle: 50GB Traffic Analysis

Let’s calculate the real cost for a typical monthly usage of 50GB of residential proxy traffic:

Provider	Price per GB	50GB Total	Difference
Bright Data	$5.04/GB	$252	🏆 $148 cheaper
Oxylabs	$8/GB	$400	—

Verdict: Bright Data saves you $148 per month on 50GB usage—that’s 37% lower cost.

However, consider volume discounts:

• Both providers offer significant enterprise pricing tiers
• Bright Data’s Dataset Marketplace can reduce data acquisition costs
• Oxylabs may offer better rates for contracts exceeding 500GB/month

Performance Benchmarks

Success Rate Comparison

Metric	Bright Data	Oxylabs	Winner
Success Rate	99.9%	99.2%	✅ Bright Data (+0.7%)
Response Time	0.45s	0.55s	✅ Bright Data (-0.1s)
IP Pool Size	72M+	175M+	✅ Oxylabs (+103M)

Trust Signals

Bright Data:

• Military-grade targeting precision
• Ethically sourced IPs with full compliance
• Industry-leading 99.9% success rate
• Trusted by Fortune 500 companies

Oxylabs:

• Largest residential network in the industry
• Tier-1 technical support team
• Highly stable connections for critical operations
• Enterprise-grade reliability

Feature Comparison

Feature	Bright Data	Oxylabs
SOCKS5 Support	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
HTTP/HTTPS	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
City-level Targeting	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
ZIP Code Targeting	✅ Yes	❌ No
ASN Targeting	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
Carrier Targeting	✅ Yes	❌ No
Browser Extension	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
API Support	✅ Yes	✅ Yes
Free Trial	7 days (Business)	7 days (Company)
Money Back Guarantee	❌ No	✅ Yes

Final Verdict

Choose Bright Data if:

• You need the best success rate (99.9%) and fastest response times
• Advanced scraping tools and dataset marketplace are valuable to you
• Granular targeting (ZIP, Carrier, ASN) is required
• You want the most cost-effective option for medium-volume usage
• Enterprise-grade dashboard and analytics matter to your team

Choose Oxylabs if:

• You need the largest IP pool (175M+) for maximum coverage
• 24/7 dedicated premium support is critical for your operations
• You’re working with emerging markets requiring extensive geo-coverage
• Enterprise contracts with volume discounts are your primary model
• Simple, reliable infrastructure is your top priority

Our Recommendation

For most developers and businesses in 2026, Bright Data offers the better value proposition. The combination of superior success rates, faster response times, advanced tools, and 37% lower costs makes it the optimal choice for enterprise scraping operations.

However, if your priority is maximum IP coverage and you require premium 24/7 enterprise support with dedicated account management, Oxylabs remains a top-tier option—especially for large-scale, mission-critical data collection operations.

---